Everyone’s Favorite Dress

pattern: McCalls 7387

fabric: Liberty twill cotton from The Fabric Store

I’m not normally one to hop on a bandwagon when the general public seems to become a fanatic of one particular thing, be it a movie, a musician, a book, or in this case, a pattern. Example: everyone I know, including my wife, has talked on and on (and on and on and on!) about what a phenom Zadie Smith is, but I just haven’t been able to make it through any of her books. I’ve started a couple of them, never imagining for one second that White Teeth wouldn’t make it’s way into my Top 20 novels before I even started reading the first page, but it turns out it just wasn’t for me. This of course doesn’t mean that it’s not an incredible book or that my wife and all those other people raving about Smith’s work don’t have excellent taste (I’m sure it is and I know that they do), but timing matters, and perhaps more importantly, nothing can be everything to everyone. I try and remember this when I get criticism for projects I have been a part of, both large and small- more often than not, someone’s disinterest in a work of art isn’t personal, it’s just subjective, and that rings true for the sewing community as well. Which is why I bring this up- I don’t want to offend anyone who loves this pattern I am about to blog about (and according to the internet, many of you do)!

I came to Pattern Review pretty late, and I still don’t use it as a resource as often as I could. It is one of the first online spaces to begin cultivating an enthusiastic sewing community, so not only are their archives pretty massive, it is also one of the largest online forums dedicated to sewcialists in existence today, and from what I can tell, it has been beneficial to hundreds of thousands of people, both technically and socially, for years. Now that so many people have blogs, I do a simple google search when I am looking for details about a specific pattern that I want to make, and usually several entries will pop up, frequently from people whose blogs I already follow. But back in the day before so many people had access to creating their own blogs and writing about personal projects, PR was the place where you could easily share information about your makes- what worked, what didn’t, how the sizing was, what mods you made, and what the final project looked like. What has interested me most lately on PR has been rifling through the annual BEST OF posts, where they determine which patterns get sewn most often with the highest reviews/success rates. A lot of the same patterns seem to make the list every year, which has it’s pros and cons- it’s cool to know which patterns have “staying power” and are TNTs for the sewing community at large, but it would also be great to see a bit more variety in what people are trying and loving.

Anyways, two patterns caught my eye when I skimmed through the lists from the past few years. McCalls 7387, a loose fitting button-up shirt dress and M6886, a fitted knit dress, drafted to be a little looser than a body-con dress. Both were very simple silhouettes that didn’t look as if they needed a lot of tinkering. As such, I decided to make a size 10/12 in the button up shirt dress with no adjustments other than grading from the bust to the waist. It has such a loose, body skimming fit and interesting details that I couldn’t imagine that it wouldn’t fit great as-is.





First of all, this pattern is REALLLLLY FUSSY. I have no idea why they drafted the button band the way they did. I understand wanting to have a concealed placket for the band, and I like that detail (or at least I did before I had to construct it) but this one was just ridiculously complicated and messy looking. On top of that, the instructions are quite lacking for this part of the pattern, so I ended up having to make the band twice, cutting new pieces from my fabric and interfacing. I haven’t made a lot of concealed plackets in my life so maybe part of my distaste for the method demonstrated in this pattern is just based on inexperience, but the last one I DID make was for the Hannah dress, and it was a dream to put together compared to this one. This dress has you cut out several placket and band pieces, a couple of which are interfaced, but the instructions don’t do a good job of letting you know which pieces go together and there is no labeling on them other than what the general name of the pieces are (I would have found it helpful if they were labeled right/left/top/bottom etc.- the illustration in the instructions do a poor job of showing which pieces are which and which directions they should be facing). Because there are so many pieces required for the button band, not only was it needlessly complicated to construct, it also looks very bulky when finished, even though I graded my seams, understitched whenever I could, and chose a fabric that was not particularly bulky (it is on the lighter side of a mid-weight fabric). My outside placket doesn’t lay down properly and instead just kind of floats open in the air, so the hidden placket doesn’t even effectively hide the buttons it’s supposed to be concealing.

Aside from the construction method of the button band, I also dislike that it isn’t applied to the length of the front openings. The band starts a few inches down from the collar of the dress and ends at some point around the knees although there is still several inches of dress left beneath it. When I was making it I had no idea it would bother me as much as it does but for some reason I think it’s really unflattering. The placket ending where it does at the bottom doesn’t bother me so much, but I think the neckline looks just awful on me. I would prefer to have a button band going all the way up to the collar as it would on a traditional button up shirt with the option to leave a few buttons undone at the neck if you want that open collar look. As drafted, the dress splays open at my chest and just…I dunno, it just doesn’t look right to me, for whatever reason.


A few other details on this dress missed the mark for me. I love the high-low hem of the version I made, but it seems much more dramatic than necessary, and I didn’t realize how long the back was until it was finished- it’s so long that I can’t wear the dress without heels (or in my case, clogs), which cuts down on the different ways I can wear it. I also don’t like that the sides have a split at each seam; I think it looks too busy. It could have benefited from one or the other design element- a high/low hem or slits up the seams- but not both. Wasn’t it Coco Chanel, that fashionable but irredeemable (IMO) Nazi spy, who said that before leaving the house you should always remove one accessory so you don’t look overdone? I feel like that’s what this pattern needed- some major detail editing. Too bad I didn’t realize it until the entire dress was complete!

My final, but most frustrating complaint about the dress is the back pattern piece. The construction of the yoke is what I originally loved best about the dress from the technical design because the folded over pieces made me think of the Hannah Dress, but unfortunately it doesn’t wear very well. Or, rather, it doesn’t wear well on my body type (more booty!) The back piece is drafted VERY wide since it is folded on top of itself to create a sort of pleated effect. But as that extra fabric falls toward the hips, the folded pleat disappears and the fabric ends up pooling around the top of my butt in this really weird way. I

It’s hard to describe, but I think it’s because the excess fabric from the top of the pattern piece isn’t graded out at the hips, it just collects in one area, and I think it’s so noticeable on me because of my butt-to-waist ratio. The way the fabric falls in the back is very unflattering, and I even tried belting it in a million different ways as a last ditch attempt to “save” this dress. FYI, cinching a wide dress that has no seamed waist has always been a look that I am decidedly NOT into, but I would do it if it made this dress work better. Unfortunately it did not. So when I wear it (and yes, as much as I am complaining about this dress, I will wear it because I love the fabric!), it will just be worn baggy with a pool of collected fabric congregating at my lower back. Unless I find some time to unpick the yoke stitching at the back and gather the extra fabric at that seam instead of leaving it pleated as drafted. We are going to Costa Rica this summer and I imagine that this dress, with a few adjustments, will be a nice, easy garment to wear on warm, windy beaches with a bathing suit underneath. But I am most likely going to have to chop that weirdly long back hem down quite a bit so that I can wear the dress with sandals. And I will sew up those unnecessary side slits too while I’m at it.

Speaking of fabric, this spring-y floral print is made from a lightweight, opaque twill by Liberty of London, which came from none other than The Fabric Store. I love the color combination and the fabric’s softness- it feels like a fabric that has already been laundered 20 times. It’s light weight lends itself very well to this style of dress, which makes it look as breezy and easy to wear as it feels (aside from that blasted button band, of course!). So far, the fabric choice is my favorite thing about this dress, but perhaps once I adjust the hem it will look a little bit better to me. The only other things I really like about the dress are the sleeves, which are not set-in. They are drafted in a stuck-on style, but with a more subtle effect, and the cuffs tie them in with the tabs on the pockets- speaking of, could you tell this dress has pockets, one on each breast? The busy fabric kind of turns the whole thing into a seeing-eye puzzle!

I was so excited about this dress when I was working on it and I am really bummed that it came out the way it did. But this has been a good reminder for me to maintain a critical eye when shopping for sewing patterns, even when everyone else seems to be raving about them. I have mentioned a certain indie pattern brand on the blog several times before that has exquisite styling, design details and branding for their company, but the patterns look horrid on me. I made several patterns of theirs in my first couple of years sewing which were almost immediately relegated to the Butthole Bin™ before I faced the harsh reality that these patterns simply weren’t suitable for my body type. I wanted so badly to hop on the band wagon with everyone else in the sewing community and stay there, but I got to a point where I couldn’t bear to spend any more time and fabric sewing a garment that I knew was most likely going to look unflattering on me. Although I usually have much better luck with Big 4 patterns, I still need to keep my eye discerning and focused, because it usually doesn’t steer me wrong (unless we are talking about that disaster that was that Vena Cava for Vogue dress I tried my hand at a couple of weeks ago! hahahaha! But I digress…)

I will be sure to share some photos of the “new” version of this button down dress with the hem and side slits fixed and hopefully the back piece adjusted as well when I get around to it. Stay tuned 🙂


9 responses to “Everyone’s Favorite Dress”

  1. Chris Avatar

    yeah – I know what you mean about being dissatisfied with the fit of a popular pattern and can see why you feel that way about this dress. That said, it looks cute on you in a casual, relaxed way and will come in handy to feel cool on those boiling hot, lazy summer days.

    Being a 5′ 10″ pear shape myself, I’ve experienced this type of disappointment, too. I always appreciate when a pattern company mentions what body type they draft for, or at least list the finished item measurements on the pattern envelope.

  2. Lia Avatar

    OH i juuust bought this pattern to make for my mom . I’ve read some other reviews that criticized the fit and that placket, so i’ve already decided to try to fix those details , but no one mentioned the fact the placket isn’t on the entire opening

    1. Jasika Nicole Avatar

      I’m sure it will turn out totally great, especially since you are already aware of some of the construction and design issues. And you can totally elongate the button band and placket fairly easily!

  3. carmen Avatar

    Try wearing it belted! I love your fabric choice.

    1. Jasika Nicole Avatar

      As I mentioned in the blog post, I don’t like belting things with ultra wide waists, but I did try it for this dress and it looked horrible.

  4. Jess Avatar

    How frustrating! But I appreciate your post, a good reminder to learn from mistakes, scrutinize patterns, and avoid things just because they’re popular. Have you seen the hints for the next Closet Case Patterns design? I’m pretty sure it’s a modern shirtdress with high-low shirttail hem, kimono sleeves, and a wide yoke (Heather made one for herself and posted it on her blog at some point…). Seems like it would have the details you love about this but without the misfit. What happened with the Vena Cava dress?! I’ve had my eye on that pattern for sooo long, will you/did you do a post on it?

    1. Jasika Nicole Avatar

      Yes, I knew of the upcoming CC pattern and am excited that it has now been released 🙂 The Vena Cava dress was too much of a nightmare to blog about but I shared a little bit of the journey on my instagram. I got to the very last steps of the pattern, literally sewing up the last couple of seams to complete the dress, before I threw the whole thing in the garbage (since the fabric is cut in such a weird way it couldn’t be salvaged for smaller project). Even if the construction methods from Vogue hadn’t been so faulty and weird (they tell you to fold over and iron the neck and front edge hems and then sew them down with a straight stitch…on knit fabric!!!) the final design was completely unflattering on me and I knew that even if I finished the dress it would be absolutely unwearable and ugly- there was literally nothing I could do to save it. And since the pieces are a bit like a puzzle, I had no idea what to do to reshape them and adjust the design details. It was a massive fail but I got some pretty hilarious photos from it. That said, lots of people had great success with the pattern, so I wouldn’t rely on my experience with it- I think by the time I realized how the dress was going to look on my body (not very cute) I just lost interest in trying to make it work.

  5. Renee Avatar

    Welp. That is terrible on you. I’m sorry that happened. But, I am really really sorry about Zadie Smith. I saw her speak at Johns Hopkins last year and had to stop myself from RUNNING DOWN THE AISLE and trying to just pet her. I feel similarly about Chimamanda Ngozi Adichie after reading Americanah. That said, “nothing can be everything to everyone” is right. My cousin didn’t like the Blacksonian (NMAAHC). He thought it didn’t have enough on Civil Rights and was flabbergasted he didn’t see something about Marcus Garvey. I on the other hand couldn’t believe the breadth of information covered and sobbed like a baby in the unexpected military section.

  6. DANA C REEVES Avatar

    Hello Jasika! I am currently attempting to make this dress (View C), but not because everyone was making it. I bought this pattern awhile back because it looked cute and then read the reviews on PR. Everyone was saying the button placket was confusing, so I put off making it until now. I accepted it as a challenge. Now that I’m knee deep into this project, I’m like OMG! I went back and re-read PR to see what advise everyone offered. Nothing was really helpful. But what really baffles me is why did everyone on PR give this dress a 4 or 5.. even the people that said they would not make it again and didn’t like the final result.. WTF!

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *