That Rachel Comey Dress

Everybody loves Rachel Comey and everybody loves Vogue 1501, but it took me a really long time to jump on the bandwagon. I appreciate Rachel Comey’s designs across the board, but I don’t think that they often suit me and my style. At first glance, some of the designs are just a little too out-there for my tastes, and others seem a little too simple, but I am learning that I should give her patterns (and probably others that I judge too quickly) a second glance. It turns out, very little of what Comey designs should be categorized as ‘simple’, and paying more attention to the technical drawings as opposed to the styling on the pattern envelope would probably do me good. Vogue seems to be a fan of matching Comey designs with abstract and/or bold fabrics, and while I LOVE a good print, I think that practice has a tendency to overwhelm the design features of a garment with as much nuanced detail as Comey’s tend to have. As ashamed as I am to admit it, I have definitely overlooked many designs simply because the styled image of the garment turned me off, so it looks like that old adage about books and covers holds true for the sewing world, too; you can’t judge a pattern by it’s envelope.

I first saw Vogue 1501 on either Heather’s blog or IG feed a while ago, before she had even sewn it up (I think she posted a pic of the pattern envelope and shared how excited she was to sew it up). I remember thinking “what a strange design!” and not giving it another thought til I saw the finished makes that she and What Katie Sews created; both were dark colored and beautiful. There was something special about the pattern that I had overlooked before, and seeing it sewn up and being worn on an actual body showed me how classy and sophisticated (and yes, very NYC Magazine Editor!) it was. So I bought the pattern, because I am nothing if not heavily influenced by my favs in the sewing community. It only sat in my craft room for a few weeks before I decided what fabric to us for it.

Interestingly enough, my experience with the fabric I chose was very similar to my experience with the pattern. I had seen the bolt in The Fabric Store several times before and gawked at the beautiful periwinkle blue of the background, but maybe because it was silk, which always requires a bit of extra work and attention) or maybe because I had no ideas of what to make with it, I just disregarded it. It wasn’t until I saw Mimi’s stunning shirtdress version in the same fabric that I felt inspired to grab it, regardless on if I had a plan for it or not, and I am so happy that I did, because this material + pattern are a match made in heaven!

Aside from the gorgeous color palette (that pale peach and blue together are EVERYTHING), I love the Art Deco inspired look of the print. I thought it would pair well with the design of Comey’s pattern, which at first glance seemed pretty modern to me, but after making it, it feels a bit more rooted in vintage elements. I get a 20s/30s vibe from the loose, blousy top paired with the knee-length skirt, but the tucked-in front makes it feel more current. I made a size 8 in the blouse and a size 10 in the skirt, which was easy to combine since the blouse and skirt are separate pieces and are only connected at the waist front by one line of stitching. I could probably have gone down a size/adjusted the blouse to make it even smaller but the loose fit works for the silhouette. I ended up having to take the skirt in significantly at the back seam where the zipper is inserted, but it was easy to do- the pleats at the front of the skirt (which are so pretty draped in this fabric) allows for a lot of flexibility in the body of the skirt, so I only needed to adjust the fit at the waist and then taper down to nothing at the hip.

I had read on Pattern Review that this dress has shoulder pads and an interesting shoulder seam gusset to accommodate the extra material at the top of the shoulder (I had totally overlooked that detail from the pattern envelope info). I wasn’t sure if I wanted shoulder pads or not so I decided to construct the dress with the gusset and just yay or nay the pads when the time came to insert them. I am generally not a fan of shoulder pads in anything other than coats, maybe because my shoulders match up pretty well with the width of my hips and don’t droop down, so pads tend to make my shoulders look incongruous with the rest of my body. Once the gussets were in, I sewed up a thin shoulder pad from some quilt backing and covered it in the dress fabric, then inserted it into the blouse. It didn’t make a significant difference with the overall shape of the dress on my figure, but you could see the edges of the shoulder pad imprinted on the inside of the blouse, which was very noticeable and messy looking. I decided to forgo the pads but I kept the gussets in because it would have been too complicated to try and remove them without ruining the fabric.

For some reason I totally forgot to use French Seams when I started sewing the blouse of this dress, so there are all kind of finishes on the inside: a couple seams are serged, most of the others are frenched, and I managed to get a few Hong Kong seams in there, too! Ha! As long as they don’t come unraveled, it doesn’t matter which technique I use.

I recognize that the busy-ness of my pattern hides a lot of the design details of the dress (something that I didn’t like about the styling on the pattern envelope), but maybe I just like my fabric print better than Vogue’s so I give it a pass. I can definitely see myself making this garment again, in a solid color this time, and maybe a few tweaks to the fit; I would be interested in removing a tad bit of length from the blouse (mine billows out a bit and I have to pull the blouse up at the shoulders so that it sits straight and doesn’t fall forward), skipping the insertion of the shoulder pad gussets, and I would also like to play around with the idea of shortening the back part of the blouse so that you can see the skirt back; a bit of a play on a crop top look while keeping the front the same. It might not work, but it’s certainly worth a try! When I envision this new version of the dress, it’s peach or orange hued with a rich, velvety texture, so let’s see if this ends up coming to fruition!


13 responses to “That Rachel Comey Dress”

  1. Gillian Avatar

    It’s bee-you-ti-ful! I loved Heather and Katie’s version too, so mo surprise I enjoy your’s as well! 😉 Great use of that print!

  2. Naia Avatar

    I love your dress and the fabric. I agree with you about the Comey pattern photos and destracting fabric. It seems like on every one of her patterns, the fabric is so distracting you cannot see what is going on with the pattern. It drives me batty.

  3. Gabrielle UpSewLate Avatar

    Ooh very nice – it’s such a great pattern, isn’t it! Love the print too (I used one quite similar for this dress too ).

  4. Anneke Caramin Avatar

    Aaah lovely! I made this in a maxi version a while back, and I feel like I need another one in my life…

  5. Charlotte E Avatar
    Charlotte E

    I love everything about this. The fabric, the shape and the fit. Well done!
    I’ve never sewn a Big 4 pattern before (possible fitting issues and bare bones instructions put me off) but clicking on the pattern link I see that all patterns are currently on sale at $5.99 so I may well be tempted to order a few to test at that price.

  6. Bella Avatar

    The pattern is so beautiful in that fabric! I made my own version in sand washed silk and it came out beautifully. I love Comey’s designs, they always have an unexpected element to them. Something interesting is that all the designer vogues are photographed in their original designer iteration, so the dress on the envelope would have come straight from Rachel Comey – Vogue doesn’t choose the fabrics for the designer garments. Kind of explains some of the busy prints that obscure the details we sewists look for 🙂

  7. Sarah Avatar

    Gorgeous! I definitely think judging a pattern by line drawings is a skill that needs to be honed – it’s so hard to look past the terrible styling sometimes!

  8. katie Avatar

    Such a dream pairing of fabric and pattern, it’s gorgeous on you. I’m happy I helped you see how cool this pattern is beyond the envelope photos. Still love my versions and wear them often. Love the sound of a solid peachy one with a shorter back!

  9. Fiona Avatar

    I have been umming and ahhhing over whether to try this pattern or not since it was released! Similar to you I love Rachel Comey designs but am just not sure how they will work on me. Seeing it on your has made me want to give it a try, probably in a darker solid. I think I mainly want to make it because I am intrigued by the constriction! Lovely dress

  10. Danneel Avatar

    Stinkin’ gorgeous! The fabric is to die for! FYI! You look great in it!

  11. Nancy Leung Avatar
    Nancy Leung

    WOW! I’m a bit of a late bloomer when it comes to the handmade fashion blog. So glad I came across yours. Love your Insta account too. This is a wonderful pairing of both fabric design and pattern. I must admit the pattern was very curious when I first saw it but as it was during an epic sale, I thought lets give it a chance as I love a good sewing/pattern piecing challenge. I judge the styling of pattern covers too but SOOOO glad for the technical sketches on the back. It strips away the questionable fabric and fit choices of the styling most of the times. Love your writing style too!

    1. Jasika Nicole Avatar

      Thanks so much for reading 🙂

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *